Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /var/www/html/fr/freeliberal.com/textpattern/lib/constants.php on line 136
Free Liberal: Coordinating towards higher values

Free Liberal

Coordinating towards higher values

An F for Academic Freedom

by Paul Jacob

Just "being a professor" doesn't make you smarter than your students. Or more grounded in reality. Or common sense.

Take Priya Venkatesan, a Dartmouth academic who teaches a class in something-or-other to do with science, postmodernism and higher or lower consciousness or something.

She is suing some of her former students. Why? Maybe it's like climbing Mount Everest: You do it to see if you can. And this professor apparently thinks modern anti-discrimination laws entitle her to go after students simply for criticizing her teaching.

Roger Kimball has the scoop over at PajamasMedia.com. He quotes Professor V's minatory email to her students. In it she merely says she is suing "some of you" under Title VII of what she blunderingly calls "anti-federal" discrimination laws. She obviously didn't like her students' class evaluations, which she ominously says she will reproduce in a book.

Don't wait for her to find a publisher. Many of the evaluations have already found their way onto the Internet. Typical criticisms include "awful," "nonsensical," "worst course ever." Sure, we can't know the quality of her teaching for certain without trekking to Dartmouth and sitting in. But from her course description and her email's grammar and logic I'm willing to credit the students' insights.

More I shan't say, as I don't wish to be named in Professor V's lawsuit. My lawyer is overworked already.

Paul Jacob's "Common Sense" is published by the Sam Adams Alliance. Their website can be visited at www.samadamsalliance.org.


« Rising Energy Prices and the Falling Dollar | Main | Is there such a thing as too much money? »

Comments

Unfortunately, many people don't actually know what "academic freedom" is. Basically it is, "the ability to speak to that of which you are an expert". That's it.

I am not overly familiar with the case, but the above commentary doesn't seem to be in any way related to "academic freedom" as the title of the article would suggest.

# posted at by Craig Schock

"Academic freedom" means nothing when the classroom instructor is a nut-job.

# posted at by David

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /var/www/html/fr/freeliberal.com/textpattern/lib/constants.php on line 136