Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /var/www/html/fr/ on line 136
Free Liberal: Coordinating towards higher values

Free Liberal

Coordinating towards higher values

401(k) -- Is it Really Your Money?

This tax shelter makes you wonder about the tax

by Fred E. Foldvary

Many workers have been saving money for retirement in 401(k) accounts. These are programs sponsored by employers in which the interest and capital gains are not taxed until the money is withdrawn. The plan is called 403(b) for nonprofit organizations. Many employers kick in additional funds when the employee puts money into the plan.

There are taxes and penalties if the account holder withdraws funds before age 59 and six months. But some account owners have been shocked to find out that they cannot withdraw their funds at all, even if they have reached retirement age.

Some of the companies that administer 401(k) funds have large losses and illiquid assets, and are blocking withdrawals. So at the very time that some unemployed workers need the funds, the same recession that put them out of work has also depleted their retirement funds and even prevented them from getting their money back.

Companies that own real estate not only have lost asset value, but have not been willing to sell their properties to pay for withdrawals. Commercial real estate is crashing as shops and offices shut down. Companies that own office buildings and shopping centers could sell these at steep losses, but that would then even further plunge the value of the shares.

But even mutual funds that have shares of stock that they could sell are refusing to sell, because the realized losses would reduce the share value for all the account holders. And so they are limiting withdrawals.

What 401(k) investors don’t understand is that funds put into the plan are not fully their own property. If you really own property, you have full control over it. A 401(k) plan is really a partnership among the account holder, the plan administrator, and the government. The government is the senor partner; it can change the rules and confiscate the account if it wants to. If your wages are subject to taxation with no limit, you don’t really own your labor. The state has ownership rights to your labor and can also restrict your labor.

Many account holders do not read the contract they sign when they get a 401(k) or 403(b). In many cases, the administrator, in effect a partner to the account, can limit withdrawals, even after the account holder reaches the retirement age. If they can limit withdrawals, they have ownership rights. If you want to make sure you can get your money out within a short time, you need to keep the assets in the account in liquid forms such as in treasury bills.

The basic problem is the income tax, which penalizes savings and investment. Congress therefore allows people to put money in accounts in which the gains are not taxed until the funds are withdrawn. But that then sets up rules which may act against the interests of the account holder when they want to withdraw “their” money.

The income tax creates fundamental problems that have no good solution except the abolition of the income tax. If taxes were instead based on land value and pollution, then wages and business profits would be tax-free. There would then be no tax advantage in retirement accounts. Some employers and financial firms could still offer accounts with early-withdrawal penalties, but the account holder would have more clout, and the contracts would be more favorable to hardship withdrawals and retirement conversions such as to annuities.

In a pure free market, there would be no mandatory governmental social security or medical plan taxes. Freed from income and payroll taxes, workers would instead put their savings into retirement plans that would grow with compound interest. They would have much more choice, and financial firms would have to cater more to the desires of their customers.

Government’s gigantic subsidy to landowners causes the boom-bust cycle and makes governments grab the wages of workers to finance the state. Public goods increase rent and land value, which is a subsidy unless the landowners pay this back. Tenants are paying an implicit tax in the higher rent caused by government services, in addition to the taxation of their wage, and the deadweight loss of truncated production caused by the taxes.

But they keep electing the politicians who do this, so I ask the worker crying because he can’t withdraw his 401(k) money, why did you vote for this?

This article first appeared in the Progress Report, Reprinted with permission.

Dr. Fred Foldvary teaches economics at Santa Clara University and is the author of several books: The Soul of Liberty, Public Goods and Private Communities, and the Dictionary of Free-Market Economics.

« Banker of the Year | Main | Audit the Fed, Then End It! »


After decades of working really hard, retirement fund is a sweet reward. However, since the economy hasn’t been on its greatest shape, lots of the options for short term funding have been drying up. Short term funding is a necessary thing to have around, and going through traditional channels such as banks isn't an option for a lot of people anymore – basically it's only open to Ken Lewis. Installment loans are an option, but some people, including senior citizens, have been thinking about raiding their retirement fund. Getting into your pension retirement plan or 401(k) funds is the last thing you want to do if you don't qualify for any withdrawals yet. The penalties are substantial, and you'll end up needing installments loans to pay them if you use retirement funds for short term funding.

Deprecated: Function get_magic_quotes_gpc() is deprecated in /var/www/html/fr/ on line 136